Achieving Peace with Justice: the International Criminal Court and Ugandan Alternative Justice Mechanisms
نویسنده
چکیده
I. BACKGROUND ON UGANDA LRA CONFLICT & THE INTERNATIONAL CRIMINAL COURT ..............................213 II. UGANDAN ALTERNATIVE JUSTICE MECHANISMS (AJM) ....................................................................223 III. ICC AVENUES FOR DEFERRAL TO AJM ...........................237 A. Security Council Request (Article 16)................................239 B. Ne Bis In Idem (Article 20)................................................244 C. Prosecutorial Discretion (Article 53)..................................246 D. Inadmissibility (Article 17) ................................................251 IV. PRINCIPLED GUIDELINES FOR DEFERRAL .....................259 A. General Framework............................................................259 B. Threshold Inquiry ...............................................................262 C. Advancement of International Criminal Justice .................265 1. Retribution........................................................266 2. Deterrence .......................................................270 3. Expressivism ....................................................273 4. Restorative Justice ............................................275 CONCLUSION...............................................................................................278
منابع مشابه
Between the Scylla and Charybdis of Prosecution and Reconciliation: the Khmer Rouge Trials and the Promise of International Criminal Justice
The issue of “justice versus peace” has long been at the center of the controversy on international prosecutions for crimes in transitional and post-conflict societies. Opponents of international prosecutions have taken umbrage at the presumption that justice can only be rendered through criminal prosecutions by an international tribunal often far removed from local realities and voiced their c...
متن کاملنقش شورای امنیت در تحقق عدالت کیفری بین المللی
Relationship between the UN Security Council, the institution of international criminal justice demonstrates a deep relationship between peace and justice. Therefore by ratification of statute of international criminal court, in different cases we can see the roles of UN Security Council in prosecute, trail and punishment those who commit the crimes within the jurisdiction of international cr...
متن کاملFactsheet – EEAS Mediation Support Project – Knowledge Product Transitional Justice in the context of Peace Mediation
Mediation efforts often take place in contexts where the conflicting parties have violated international human rights or humanitarian law and where justice issues arise. Transitional justice is a multidimensional long-term undertaking, defined by the EU Council document ‘Transitional Justice and the ESDP’ as “a framework for confronting past abuse as a component of a major political transformat...
متن کاملدفاع اختلال روانی در زمان ارتکاب جرم: تقابل حقوق متهم با منافع قربانی در حقوق کیفری بینالمللی
Following the occurrence of international crimes in the territory of yugoslavia and Rwanda, UN security council established international criminal tribunals and after a while international criminal court was presented so that it be an answer to crimes, perpetrators as responsible and healing victims. But because of the aforementioned courts couldn't ignore the accused rights, regulations predic...
متن کاملConference Report: New York City's Criminal Courts are we Achieving Justice?
On October 18, 2003, more than one hundred professionals from the five boroughs of New York City came together to identify, evaluate, and begin to solve some of the complex problems embedded in the culture, operations, and practice in New York City’s Criminal Courts. The conference planners focused on five problems that have undermined the pursuit of justice in New York City’s Criminal Court sy...
متن کامل